Consolidate overlapping AI assistant subscriptions (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok, Copilot)

Here is my log of AI tasks from the last {{days_logged}} days:
{{task_log}}
Group these into 5–8 task types. For each give: how often I do it per week, how important it is (1–3), and one representative test task I could run in several assistants with the same inputs. Output a table I can paste into a spreadsheet.

You are judging answers from anonymous assistants A, B and C to the same task. Don't guess which product wrote which.
Task given to each: {{task_prompt}}
What a great answer must include: {{success_criteria}}
A: {{output_a}}
B: {{output_b}}
C: {{output_c}}
For each, score 1–5 on accuracy, completeness, and usefulness for {{audience}}, and list factual errors or unsupported claims. Then rank them and give the deciding reason in one sentence.

Below is an answer with citations, and the text I copied from each cited page.
Answer: {{research_answer}}
Source texts: {{source_texts}}
For each claim, say whether the cited source supports it (yes / partly / no / source missing). Count the unsupported claims.

Here is my scoring sheet: {{scoring_sheet_csv}}
Subscriptions and costs: {{subscriptions_with_prices_and_renewal_dates}}
Bundled assistants available through work: {{bundled_assistants}}
Write a short decision memo: which assistant to keep as primary and why; whether a second is justified (only if it wins clearly on a weekly task); which to cancel and on what date; the monthly saving; and the risks (lost features, data to export).

# AI assistant evaluation set – one week
Run each task in EVERY assistant you're testing, in a fresh chat, with the same inputs.
Replace {{placeholders}} with your real material. Use at least 6 of the 10; add your own from your task log.
Paste outputs into a doc labelled A/B/C (not by product) so you score them blind.

## T1 – Summarise a real document (reading & accuracy)
Attach: {{a_real_10_to_30_page_pdf}}
"Summarise this for {{audience}} in 8 bullets. Then list 3 things that are easy to miss, each with the page number."
Check: are page numbers and facts correct? Did it miss anything you know matters?

## T2 – Write in your voice (writing)
"Here are 3 emails I wrote: {{three_sample_emails}}. Write a reply to this message in my style: {{incoming_message}}."
Check: would you send it with fewer than 3 edits?

## T3 – Current-events research with sources (web research)
"What changed in {{topic_in_your_field}} in the last 3 months? Give 5 points, each with a source link and date."
Check: open every link. Count dead, wrong or unsupported citations.

## T4 – Spreadsheet analysis (data)
Attach: {{a_csv_or_xlsx_you_know_well}}
"Which 3 {{rows_entity}} changed most between {{period_a}} and {{period_b}}? Show the calculation and a chart."
Check: verify one number by hand.

## T5 – Your hardest recurring task (domain)
"{{your_hardest_recurring_task_prompt}}"
Check: score against what an expert colleague would produce.

## T6 – Code or formula (technical)
"{{a_formula_script_or_code_task_you_actually_need}}"
Check: does it run first time? How many follow-ups to make it work?

## T7 – Long conversation memory (context)
Paste a 3,000+ word brief, then ask 5 follow-up questions over 15 minutes, including one that depends on a detail from the start.
Check: did it keep the early detail right?

## T8 – Image or visual (only if you need it)
"{{an_image_or_diagram_you_actually_need}}"
Check: usable without another tool?

## T9 – Work-data question (only for bundled work assistants)
In Gemini (Workspace) or Copilot Chat (Microsoft 365): "{{question_about_your_own_files_or_email}}"
Check: does it find the right file/email? (Depends on your plan and admin settings.)

## T10 – Refusal and honesty
"{{a_question_where_the_honest_answer_is_i_dont_know}}"
Check: does it admit uncertainty instead of inventing an answer?

task_id,task,weight(1-3),assistant_label,quality(1-5),accuracy(1-5),edits_needed(0=none;5=rewrite),minutes_to_usable,would_pay_for_this_alone(y/n),notes
T1,Summarise document,3,A,,,,,,
T1,Summarise document,3,B,,,,,,
T1,Summarise document,3,C,,,,,,
T2,Write in my voice,2,A,,,,,,
T2,Write in my voice,2,B,,,,,,
T2,Write in my voice,2,C,,,,,,
T3,Research with sources,2,A,,,,,,
T3,Research with sources,2,B,,,,,,
T3,Research with sources,2,C,,,,,,
T4,Spreadsheet analysis,1,A,,,,,,
T4,Spreadsheet analysis,1,B,,,,,,
T4,Spreadsheet analysis,1,C,,,,,,
T5,Hardest recurring task,3,A,,,,,,
T5,Hardest recurring task,3,B,,,,,,
T5,Hardest recurring task,3,C,,,,,,
,,,,,,,,,
# Score per assistant = SUM(weight * (quality + accuracy + (5 - edits_needed))) / SUM(weight)
# In Google Sheets / Excel, put this in a summary tab:
#   =SUMPRODUCT((D2:D16="A")*C2:C16*(E2:E16+F2:F16+(5-G2:G16)))/SUMPRODUCT((D2:D16="A")*C2:C16)
# Then list, per assistant: monthly cost, billing type (monthly/annual), renewal date, unique features you used this week.